Turn Failure into Success
Mastering the 'Tell me about a time you failed' question
One of the most critical and frequently asked questions in Engineering Manager (EM) interviews, especially at top tech companies, is: “Tell me about a time you failed.” While daunting, this question provides a unique opportunity to showcase your growth, resilience, and leadership skills.
Why This Question Matters So Much in EM Interviews
Tech companies like Google, Meta, and Amazon emphasize behavioral interviews to assess soft skills like accountability, decision-making, and adaptability. This question is a favorite because it highlights how you navigate setbacks, a key quality for effective leadership. As an EM, your ability to handle failure sets the tone for your team and builds trust within the organization.
Here’s why interviewers love this question:
Shows Self-Awareness: How well do you understand and articulate your mistakes?
Reveals Problem-Solving Skills: How did you recover or mitigate the damage?
Demonstrates Learning and Growth: How have you improved from this experience?
Mastering the Answer with the STAR Framework
Using the STAR framework (Situation, Task, Action, Result) ensures your response is clear, structured, and impactful:
Situation: Set the stage with relevant context.
Task: Explain your role and the stakes involved.
Action: Highlight your actions to address the failure.
Result: Share the outcome and lessons learned.
Step-by-Step Guide to Crafting Your Answer
1. Choose the Right Failure
Select an example that’s relevant to the role and demonstrates meaningful growth. Avoid catastrophic failures or personal blunders that can cast doubt on your professionalism. Instead, focus on a situation where you took a calculated risk or faced an unexpected challenge.
2. Set the Context
Use the “Situation” step to provide just enough background for the interviewer to understand the scenario. Be concise but descriptive.
Example: “In my previous role as a project manager, I was responsible for delivering a critical product feature within a tight deadline.”
3. Highlight Your Responsibility
Explain your role and what was at stake. This helps frame the significance of the situation.
Example: “My task was to coordinate cross-functional teams to ensure timely delivery while maintaining high quality.”
4. Be Honest About the Failure
Acknowledge what went wrong without deflecting blame. Authenticity is key here.
Example: “We missed the deadline due to my underestimation of the testing phase’s complexity, which caused a ripple effect across the timeline.”
5. Emphasize Your Actions
Showcase how you responded to the failure. This is your chance to highlight your problem-solving and leadership skills.
Example: “Once I realized the bottleneck, I immediately initiated a retrospective with the team to identify improvement areas. We reallocated resources, adjusted our timeline, and implemented daily check-ins to improve communication.”
6. Focus on the Lessons Learned
This is the most critical part of your answer. Demonstrate self-awareness and how you’ve applied these lessons to achieve better outcomes.
Example: “From this experience, I learned to allocate more time for testing and to involve QA in the planning stages. This approach has since helped me deliver subsequent projects on time.”
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Blaming Others: Take responsibility for your part in the failure.
Lack of Specifics: Avoid vague statements; provide concrete details.
Dwelling on Negatives: Shift the focus to what you learned and how you’ve grown.
Overly Long Answers: Be concise and to the point.
Example Answer
Let us take a look at another example:
Situation: “In my role as a team lead, I was overseeing a product launch for a key client. We had an aggressive timeline to meet their market demands.”
Task: “My job was to ensure all deliverables were completed on time while coordinating with marketing, design, and engineering teams.”
Action: “Midway through the project, I realized we hadn’t accounted for a critical compliance review. This oversight delayed our launch. To address this, I facilitated an emergency review, worked with stakeholders to prioritize tasks, and created a detailed checklist for future launches.”
Result: “Although the launch was delayed by two weeks, the client appreciated our commitment to quality and compliance. Moving forward, I implemented pre-launch compliance reviews as a standard process, reducing similar risks.”
Final Tips to Nail This Question
Practice: Rehearse your answer to ensure it’s natural and confident.
Tailor Your Example: Align your story with the job’s requirements.
Stay Positive: Frame failure as a stepping stone to success.
Be Relevant: Choose examples aligned with the role’s key competencies.
By following this guide, you’ll be well-equipped to turn a challenging question into an opportunity to shine. Remember, everyone experiences failure—it’s how you handle it that sets you apart.
Want More Insights Like This?
If you found this guide helpful, there’s plenty more where that came from! Subscribe to Cracking the EM Interview to receive actionable tips on cracking interviews, excelling in leadership roles, and navigating the tech industry.